raw.space

field/the-web-we-are-already-in

The web we're already in

On the single web of care and harm we are already held by

Look at the morning before it is fully yours. The coffee was grown by hands you will never shake, picked in a country you may never visit, carried across an ocean by a crew you will never count. The water came from an aquifer filled by rain on mountains you have never seen. The light in the room arrived down a wire that runs back to turbines and power stations and the quarterly returns of people who will never learn your name. You did not make this morning. A few hundred strangers did, and most of them are not here to be thanked.

And the same web that feeds you is the one that harms. The same threads, rather than a separate dark web running alongside the bright one. The hands that grew the coffee may be a child's. The aquifer is draining faster than the rain can fill it. The light is sold to you at a profit by people who would burn more of the world to keep selling it. There is no clean web of care to step into, set apart from the web of extraction. There is one web, and it does both.

You are less of an individual than you were taught. The calcium in your bones was made in old stars. The microbes in your gut, without which you could not digest a meal or hold a steady mood, may outnumber the cells you think of as yourself. You are nearer to an ecosystem than to a unit, a standing meeting of other lives, on loan and passing through.

It runs well past the human. Under a forest floor, trees are joined root to root by threads of fungus, and along them an old tree will feed a struggling seedling, or pass word of an insect attack down the line. Robin Wall Kimmerer calls the way of speaking that takes this seriously a grammar of animacy, the habit of treating the living world as a someone rather than a something. The catch is that the same world, spoken of as a someone, is being counted and priced and traded as a something, often by the people most fluent in the language of care.

We are trained not to see any of this, because not seeing it pays. A system that runs on unpaid care has every reason to keep the care invisible: the cooking, the minding, the checking-in, the quiet holding-up of everyone who then walks out the door to compete as though they had made themselves. When the official systems fail, as they did when the wards filled and the governments looked away, it is this unpaid web that catches people, and is thanked, and is sent back to being invisible. The myth of the self-made individual is a balance sheet, not an honest mistake.

Look closely and the care and the harm are not even housed in different people. The care worker minding another family's parents has her own children minded by someone else's grandmother. The farmer who feeds the city cannot afford the food he grows. The solar panel that cleared the air over one town was made in a place its making poisoned. You are held up by the labour of people you will never meet, and you hold others down by yours, mostly without knowing whom, or how, or that you are doing it at all.

So living in the web we are already in is the harder thing: there is only the one web, and we are tangled the whole way through it, with no way to choose the web of care and leave the web of harm behind. To see the whole of it at once. To owe thanks and to owe answers to the same crowd of strangers. To let your comfort and your complicity be one fact rather than two. The web does not ask to be loved. It asks to be seen whole, which is harder, and then to be answered for.